Monday, November 23, 2009

Welcome!

Background
Welcome to my blog on higher education mergers. This topic became a passion of mine while working (and a graduate student) at my alma mater, The University of Toledo (UT). In fall 2005, it was announced that UT would merge on July 1, 2006 with the Medical University of Ohio (MUO), formerly the Medical College of Ohio (MCO). With the stroke of Governor Bob Taft's pen, legislative approval was complete and UT added another campus, a medical school and related fields, an academic hospital and a few thousand more students. The institution also roughly doubled its budget and workforce. Changes of this magnitude are uncommon in colleges and universities, but not unprecedented. The extreme nature of this process piqued my interest, especially considering the politically-charged atmosphere in Toledo in the several years preceding the merger. In fact, in fall 2005 I wrote a paper for my history of higher education class on the history of the Medical University of Ohio and its relationship to The University of Toledo. Over the course of that fall semester, news of the merger became public and my research became more relevant. What was proposed as a University of Toledo medical school in the early 1960s never came to be, as the Medical College of Ohio was founded separately. More than 40 years later, the institutions would end up united as one.

When it came time to decide a topic for my dissertation, little else came to mind besides writing on the merger. It was simply a matter of deciding what aspect of the merger I wanted to study. I was fascinated by the ability of institutional leaders to execute such a tremendous management exercise in a climate of highly organized faculty, a UT campus battered by a failed presidency in the early 2000s and a local newspaper with a history of vigorous criticism of the university. Somehow the two university presidents composed, rehearsed and conducted a masterpiece of a performance to bring this endeavor to fruition. When the merger became public, all major decisions were already addressed. There were answers, and the idea resonated in a climate of continuing decreases of the state-share of instruction. Questions abounded as to how we would cope, and the merger notion provided one enormous way of attacking the problem. While the merger was never proposed exclusively for financial benefit, financial reasons were recognized in a consultant's report. Major benefits centered around enhanced academic and business synergies between the two institutions. In the end, the presidents "had all their ducks in a row," and executed the early stages of the merger with precision.

My study initially centered exclusively around an examination of the UT-MUO merger, but I added other institutions as time went on. In December 2009 I relocated to South Florida and accepted a position as director of development for the Fischler School of Education and Human Services at Nova Southeastern University (NSU). This was a tremendous opportunity for me in several ways, but an added benefit that I realized over the course of the interview process was that NSU had also been involved with a merger. In 1994, Nova University merged with Southeastern University of the Health Sciences. Southeastern, located in North Miami Beach, brought a college of osteopathic medicine to Nova, as well as allied health programs, and built new facilities on Nova's Main Campus in Davie, Fla., just west of Fort Lauderdale. NSU is the pilot site for my study. The other case institution is the University of Colorado Denver (UCD). UCD was formed with the 2004 consolidation of the University of Colorado at Denver and the University of Colorado Health Sciences Center. The main campus is in downtown Denver, and the Health Sciences campus relocated to the Fitzsimmons Campus in Aurora. Of note, all of these mergers are of similar type - comprehensive, metropolitan universities merging with free-standing academic health science institutions (adding a medical school).

The topic I settled on for my study is an examination of the executive decision-making processes in the above-mentioned university mergers. I want to know the methods of decision-making employed during the early-onset periods of the mergers and if these methods were along the lines of traditional academic decision-making, or more of a modern, top-down business model. Some have suggested (Eckel & Kezar, 2006) that higher education management is moving away from shared governance, and more towards top-down modern business approaches. My research may reveal that the merger decision-making was reflective of one of the two approaches. My conceptual framework uses the garbage can model of organizational choice (Cohen, March, & Olsen, 1972).

The Blog
I intend for this blog to serve as a repository for relevant news and discussion on current college and university mergers. A scan of the media today highlights several major mergers in the United States and abroad currently under discussion or in various stages of implementation. I will provide links to stories about these mergers and as well as commentary. My intent is that this blog serve as a resource for those seeking more information about higher education mergers. By no means will this be a comprehensive clearinghouse of all possible merger information, but the intent is that it will focus on the major mergers of the day, the impetus for these mergers and political context surrounding them and the implementation of the mergers. Lastly, where appropriate, I will provide commentary including personal views of the mergers in question. My opinions expressed are exclusively mine, and are not representative of any academic institution. Others are welcome to comment on my posts and opinions, and I will not censure or edit these comments unless they are personally or otherwise offensive in nature.

Future postings will provide a brief history of higher education mergers in the United States, as well as highlight certain specific elements of mergers. This will be followed by an ongoing reporting and dialogue of current mergers in various stages.

Please feel free to comment or e-mail me at any time. Thank you for your interest!